Best SEO Companies in NY

There is no single best SEO company in New York. The agencies serving this market fall into five working models, and the right one depends on whether you need niche industry knowledge, borough-level local rankings, enterprise scale across channels, paid and organic run as one system, or reputation repair. Picking the wrong model is the most common and most expensive mistake New York businesses make.

New York is harder to rank in than almost any other US market. Competition is dense in nearly every vertical, cost per click in legal, medical, dental, home services, and financial services runs among the highest in the country, and search results split by borough. A plumber in Brooklyn and a plumber in Manhattan are competing in two separate result sets. Add generative engine optimisation for AI Overviews, ChatGPT, and Perplexity, and the shortlist matters far more than the search.

This guide covers 10 SEO agencies serving the New York metro, grouped by working model:

• Niche specialists who work in one industry only and already know its platforms and compliance rules
• Local NYC generalists who focus on Google Business Profile, map pack placement, and neighbourhood queries
• Enterprise full-service agencies running SEO, paid media, and web under one contract
• Paid-first hybrids where search advertising leads and SEO is built on the same intent data
• Reputation-led firms for cases where negative search results, not rankings, are the bottleneck

Each entry lists services, team size, published pricing where available, contract terms, who it suits, and when to look elsewhere. Contact details are included so you can shortlist and call directly. Where a figure comes from an agency's own marketing rather than an independent source, we say so.

10 Best SEO Companies in NY

The 10 companies below fall into five working models. Match the model to your situation before comparing price. Note that three of the ten are headquartered outside New York City, which is not a disqualifier but is worth knowing before you call.

1. Zinda Agency

• Model: Industry-exclusive SEO, branding, and web studio 
• Founder and CEO: Malik Ali 
• Team: Approximately 10 
• Markets served: Canada, United States, United Kingdom, and the UAE

Zinda Agency is the pick for New York real estate professionals who want an SEO partner that already speaks the industry. The firm states plainly that it does not serve multiple industries, working only with real estate, which is why it already understands IDX, MLS platforms, compliance, and the KPIs agents are judged on. Its stated mission is helping top REALTORS grow by rebuilding brand, technology, and process, improving online presence, and automating sales and marketing.

Services

• SEO: Search optimisation delivered alongside branding and website design rather than as an isolated retainer
• Technical foundation: Sites built fast-loading and properly structured so they surface for queries like "realtor near me" and "homes for sale in [city]"
• Brand identity: Logo, colour palette, typography, and brand voice
• Custom websites: Built from scratch rather than templates with minor changes
• Collateral: Social graphics, property video packages, brochures, business cards, and outdoor advertising

Ten specialists spanning graphic design, strategy, web development, content creation, and project management, with every engagement scoped from a consultation instead of a fixed package.

Zinda states that it is trusted by number one RE/MAX brokers, and publishes a client testimonial describing a two-year working relationship covering website and SEO rankings. Portfolio work includes luxury agents and Vancouver developments. These are the agency's own published references rather than independently verified case studies.

Best for: New York realtors, teams, and brokerages who want SEO, brand, and site handled by one specialist team.

Consider elsewhere if: You are outside real estate, since Zinda deliberately does not take those clients. Also weigh the location. The agency is based in Vancouver with no New York office, so if you want in-person meetings or a team working your local market in your time zone, one of the Manhattan or Long Island firms below will suit you better.

Contact Details: 

• Phone: +1 (604) 200-3536

• Email: zindacanada@gmail.com

2. Mimvi SEO

• Model: AI-forward local SEO agency 
• Founded: 2015 
• CEO: Marcus Becker 
• Coverage: NYC five boroughs and Long Island

Mimvi is one of the most visible SEO names in New York and the most search-native of the local generalists. The agency specialises in AI-powered SEO and GEO services for NYC and Long Island businesses, bringing over a decade of experience across SEO, web design, and digital marketing. All work is done in-house, and the firm reports 10+ years of building SEO plans across niches.

Service lines

• Search engine optimisation, web design and development, and PPC advertising
• In-house website design and development built around user experience and SEO best practice
• SEM and PPC campaign management
• Neighbourhood-level local SEO across Midtown, SoHo, Tribeca, and the Upper East Side
• SEO integrated into site architecture, map visibility, structured content, and paid search

Mimvi recommends businesses budget a minimum of $1,000 per month with a three-month commitment, and builds a customised plan after an initial consultation rather than quoting from a menu. Its Semrush agency listing places the project range at $0 to $5,000 with a 5.0 average rating across 70 or more client reviews.

Alongside its Manhattan headquarters, the agency operates from Commack on Long Island and Boston. It describes itself as an award winner for its Long Island campaigns, a claim published on its own site rather than by a named awarding body.

Best for: NYC and Long Island small-to-mid businesses wanting local rankings plus AI search visibility.

Consider elsewhere if: You need enterprise-scale multi-market execution.

Contact Details: 

• Phone: 1-917-477-6552
• Address: 375, PARK AVE #2607, NEW YORK, NY 10152
• Email: seo@mimvi.com

3. Blue Ocean Global Technology

• Model: Reputation-led SEO and digital transformation 
• Founded: 2012 
• Team: 1–50 
• CEO and Co-Founder: Sameer Somal

Blue Ocean is the specialist to call when search visibility and reputation are the same problem. Established as a minority-owned small business, it provides digital transformation, business consulting, and technology development, with analytics, creative, legal, marketing, and strategy professionals working together. Its core focus is building reputations and creating digital assets that grow brand equity, backed by reputation management that folds in SEO, social media marketing, and web development.

Distinctive capability

• Mitigating defamatory content and repairing damaged reputations after crisis, legal, or PR issues surface online
• Testifying in court as subject matter expert witnesses
• Expert consulting in legal cases involving digital marketing, online defamation, SEO, and IP disputes
• Serving both direct clients and an exclusive partner group of PR, law, digital marketing, and web development agencies

CEO and co-founder Sameer Somal is a CFA Charterholder, a CFP® professional, and a Chartered Alternative Investment Analyst. He is also co-founder of Girl Power Talk and a regular contributor on reputation management and technology.

Best for: Law firms, financial services, executives, and any brand where negative search results are the bottleneck.

Consider elsewhere if: You want straightforward local map-pack rankings on a small budget.

Contact Details: 

• Phone: +1.623.283.6176
• Address: 70 Pine Street Suite 1324 New York, NY 10005
• Email: info@blueoceanglobaltech.com

4. Top New York SEO

Model: Full-service local SEO agency

Top New York SEO is the most budget-transparent option on this list, publishing a tiered enquiry range rather than hiding behind "contact us." The agency positions itself as a full-service SEO firm covering everything from basic keyword research to technical SEO, with continuous KPI monitoring and reporting. It advertises a 100% white-hat approach across all campaigns.

Services

• SEO, web design, and digital marketing
• Social media marketing
• PPC advertising
• Reputation management

The agency's own site reports 265 or more clients worldwide and more than 2,450 pages ranking on page one, achieved over roughly four years of trading. Both figures are self-reported and are not independently audited. It advertises 24/7 email and phone support.

Enquiry brackets published on the site run $400 to $800, $800 to $1,500, $1,500 to $3,000, $3,000 to $10,000, and $10,000 and above per engagement, useful for gauging fit before a call.

Best for: SMBs who want a defined entry price and a single Manhattan point of contact.

Consider elsewhere if: You need named case studies. The site publishes testimonials without verifiable client attribution, and the agency does not publish a founding date, team size, or named leadership.

Contact Details: 

• Phone: (646) 452-5272
• Address: 594 Broadway Suite 701, New York, NY 10012, United States
• Email: support@topnewyorkseo.company

5. SmartSites

• Model: Enterprise full-service digital marketing 
• Founded: 2011 
• Founders: Alex and Michael Melen

SmartSites is the largest agency on this list and the strongest fit for businesses that need scale rather than a boutique relationship. Founded in 2011 by brothers Alex and Michael Melen, both with Fortune 500 and Ivy League experience, the agency provides web design, SEO, and PPC marketing. It manages over $100 million per year in advertising spend across six offices and 350 or more employees worldwide.

Its growth record is the best documented of any firm here. Inc.'s own company profile lists SmartSites on the Inc. 5000 for nine consecutive years, from 2017 through 2025, ranking number 3,418 on the 2025 list. The agency marked its fifteenth anniversary in April 2026.

Services

• SEO, PPC management, web design and development, email and SMS marketing, social media management, and ecommerce marketing

Alex Melen serves as Co-CEO and CFO, previously heading digital analytics on the Walmart account at Starcom MediaVest Group, and founded T35 Hosting in the late 1990s. He was named one of America's Top 25 Best Entrepreneurs by BusinessWeek in 2006 and graduated from Babson College with honours. Michael Melen is a Cornell University graduate who sold his first internet company at 19.

The agency typically requires 12-month commitments and serves legal, healthcare, automotive, and B2B clients, with local SEO folded into broader campaigns rather than run as a dedicated Map Pack service.

Best for: Mid-market and enterprise businesses with substantial budgets wanting one vendor across channels.

Consider elsewhere if: You want month-to-month flexibility or dedicated local search work.

Contact Details: 

• Phone: (201) 870-6000
• Address: 45 Eisenhower Drive, Suite 520, Paramus, NJ 07652 

6. Digital Drew SEM

• Model: Paid-search-led agency with SEO attached 
• Founder and CEO: Drew Blumenthal

Digital Drew is the pick if paid and organic need to run as one system rather than two disconnected retainers. Founder Drew Blumenthal leads a team blending agency and Fortune 500 experience across Google Ads, Meta, SEO, web development, email, and white-label services. Blumenthal is also the author of Digital Drew's Playbook.

Services

• Google Ads, campaign strategy and build, keyword research, Shopping and feed management, retargeting, A/B testing
• Meta and LinkedIn campaigns with creative testing, audience builds, and pixel and event setup
• Technical SEO, content strategy, keyword research, on-page optimisation, and reporting tied to revenue rather than ranking position
• Attribution dashboards and analytics
• White-label management for other agencies in exchange for a management fee

The agency states that accounts are covered across disciplines by senior specialists rather than handed to a single freelancer or junior account manager logging in monthly. Its Semrush agency listing places typical project size at $1,000 to $2,500, with a 5.0 average rating across 60 or more client reviews.

Best for: Businesses running paid media that want SEO built on the same intent data.

Consider elsewhere if: You want SEO-only depth, since the centre of gravity here is paid search.

Contact Details: 

• Phone: +1 917-513-0533 
• Address: 110 E 28th Street, 10th Floor, New York, NY 10016
• Email: drew@digitaldrewsem.com

7. Jives Media

• Model: Award-winning performance marketing agency 
• Founded: 2012 
• Founder and President: Jay Ives 
• Team: 10–49 reported on Clutch

Jives Media brings the widest award record on this list. It is a Forbes-recognised performance marketing agency and five-time Clutch Agency of the Year winner, working across SEO, paid media, conversion strategy, analytics, and AI-driven search visibility. Founder Jay Ives was named to Forbes' 30 Under 30 list for marketing and advertising in 2023, and previously led marketing at Silicon Valley companies including Poshmark and Thumbtack. The agency serves clients from early-stage startups to Fortune 500 corporations.

Services

• SEO covering high-intent keywords, site structure, and long-term content
• Website and brand execution, messaging, UX, and conversion design
• Landing page and funnel optimisation
• Analytics tying spend to CAC, LTV, and revenue
• Web design, hosting, PPC, and social media management

Jives argues most agencies run paid, SEO, and web in isolation, and instead feeds ad creative performance into SEO strategy while ranking pages inform ad targeting.

Minimum project size of $1,000, hourly rate $100 to $149, with services delivered in English, Spanish, and French. The agency works on project or retainer terms and offers free initial evaluations. Its Clutch profile carries a 5.0 average across more than 170 verified reviews.

Best for: Brands wanting paid, organic, and CRO coordinated under one accountable team.

Consider elsewhere if: You want a New York headquartered team. The agency is San Francisco based with a New York office, so your senior lead may sit on Pacific time.

Contact Details:

• Phone: (650) 420-7455
• Address: San Francisco (HQ) with a New York office at 800 6th Avenue, Suite 36C, NY 10001
• Email: info@jivesmedia.com

8. Main Street ROI

• Model: Small-business SEO agency with a training arm 
• Founded: 2010 
• Co-founders: Phil Frost (CEO) and Pete Kennedy (President)

Main Street ROI is the most education-forward option here, built for owners who want to understand what they are buying. The agency has helped thousands of small businesses build profitable digital marketing campaigns since 2010. Services span SEO, Google Ads, Facebook Ads, and WordPress website development, with a mission of simplifying online marketing and ensuring measurable return.

Each client receives a Client Success Manager as primary contact plus a dedicated SEO consultant, marketing technologist, web developer, and content writer, with both founders overseeing all campaigns. All team members are US-based. Monthly SEO services require a six-month minimum commitment.

Frost's marketing writing has been published on Forbes.com, Inc.com, Adweek, and MSN.com. He holds a Master of Engineering Management from Thayer School of Engineering and Tuck School of Business, plus BA and BE degrees from Dartmouth College. Co-founder Pete Kennedy serves as President, bringing SEO strategy and direct-response copywriting expertise. The agency was ranked among New York City's best SEO companies by SEOblog.com.

Best for: Small business owners who want a named senior team plus training to hold the agency accountable.

Consider elsewhere if: You need enterprise-scale multi-market campaigns, or you want month-to-month terms.

Contact Details: 

• Phone: (646) 470-3753
• Address: 80 Orville Drive Suite 100 - #207 Bohemia, NY 11716

9. Hozio

• Model: Long Island local SEO and web design 
• Founded: 2009 
• Founders: Steven Orandello and John Bosco

Hozio is the deepest option on hyper-local Long Island search and runs on a no-contract model. The agency reports 16 or more years in business, 550 or more clients, and 50 or more in-house experts, covering on-site optimisation, local SEO, content development, and link building. Orandello and Bosco met in the mortgage industry and moved into marketing ahead of the 2008 downturn, founding several companies before combining them into Hozio in 2009. The focus is town-level visibility rather than broad regional targeting.

Services

• Core SEO: On-page, off-page, technical, and local
• Keyword research, link building, Google Business Profile management
• Website, ad, and SEO copywriting
• AI-SEO: AI search optimisation, GEO, and AI Overview visibility
• Brand identity, positioning and messaging, competitor research, logo and visual identity, brand guidelines
• Social media, GMB, and PPC for Long Island, NYC, and nationwide clients

No contracts, transparent monthly reporting, dedicated account managers who walk clients through results, and more than 17 analytics tools in use. Client counts and years in business are the agency's own reported figures.

Best for: Long Island and outer-borough service businesses wanting local dominance without a lock-in.

Contact Details: 

• Phone: (631) 750-6295
• Base: 5439 Sunrise Highway, Floor 2, Holbrook, NY, with a Manhattan address at 405 Lexington Ave

10. 5Boro Digital

• Model: SMB digital marketing platform with a home-services niche 
• Coverage: New York, New Jersey, Connecticut

5Boro Digital is the most vertical-focused of the NYC generalists, with a stated concentration in HVAC and home services. The agency describes itself as results-driven and specialising in local SEO, Google Ads, web design, and HVAC lead generation. Located in the Financial District, it positions itself as a marketing platform for small and medium businesses with an all-in-one reporting layer covering SEO, PPC, and social media. Like Hozio, it advertises month-to-month terms with no contracts.

Services

• Local and national SEO, web design and development, paid search management, social media management, mobile app development, reputation management, content strategy, and email marketing
• Branding alongside local SEO and PPC
• Local SEO delivered across Connecticut, New Jersey, and New York

Positioning: The agency argues that hiring a separate web designer, SEO specialist, and ads manager fragments results, and consolidates all of it under one team. It markets a "USA White Hat" service suite.

Best for: HVAC, plumbing, and other home-services businesses across the NY tri-state area.

Consider elsewhere if: You are in a technical B2B or enterprise category, or you want published leadership and case studies before committing.

Contact Details: 

• Phone: (914) 200-3610 
• Address: 99 Wall St ste. 3031, New York, NY 10005
• Email: info@5BoroDigital.com

How to Choose the Right SEO Company in New York

Choose based on the model that fits your situation, then verify the deliverables, not the pitch. GoodFirms alone has verified 769 SEO companies in New York, so the shortlist matters more than the search.

Seven filters that separate the real options:

1. Model fit. Niche specialist, local generalist, enterprise full-service, paid-first hybrid, or reputation-led. Each solves a different problem.
2. Who does the work. Ask for the named senior person on your account and how many other accounts they carry.
3. Contract terms. Some agencies require 12-month commitments, some run six months, others are month-to-month. Neither is wrong, but know which you signed.
4. Deliverable specificity. A real proposal names page counts, link targets, content volume, and technical fixes. A vague one names "SEO."
5. Reporting cadence. Monthly reports tied to leads and revenue, not ranking screenshots.
6. AI search readiness. Ask how they handle AI Overviews, ChatGPT, and Perplexity citation. This is now a separate discipline from classic SEO.
7. Local proof. Request two clients in your borough or vertical, then check their rankings yourself.

One extra test worth applying to any listicle, including this one. When an agency states a client count, a review score, or an award, ask where the number comes from. Most figures published by agencies are self-reported. Independent sources such as Inc., Clutch, and Semrush agency listings can be checked in a minute, and the gap between the two tells you a lot.

Why Choose Zinda Agency

Zinda is the right call for one specific New York buyer: the real estate professional. The agency serves only real estate, so it already understands IDX, MLS platforms, compliance requirements, and the metrics agents are measured on, which is the translation layer you pay for elsewhere.

What that means in practice:

• SEO built on the right foundation. Sites are structured for speed, crawlability, and the local queries buyers actually type, rather than optimised after the fact.
• One team across brand, site, and search. Identity, conversion-focused website, listing and social templates, and search visibility handled together.
• Custom builds, not resold themes. Every site is built from scratch around the agent's brand, market, and business goals.
• Senior attention. Ten specialists, packages scoped from consultation, and personalised attention as a stated advantage of the team's size.
• Top-producer work. The agency reports working with number one RE/MAX brokers and publishes multi-year client relationships covering both website and SEO rankings.

Start with a free consultation and a search audit before committing budget. 

Final Thoughts

Shortlist by model, not by ranking position. A real estate brokerage, a defamation case, and an HVAC company each need a different agency, and no single firm on this list wins all three. Ask for the named senior lead, the contract term, and two verifiable clients in your vertical, then check their rankings yourself before the second call. New York's SEO market rewards diligence at the shortlist stage far more than it rewards budget. Three good conversations beat ten rushed ones.

Frequently Asked Questions

How Much Does Seo Cost In New York?

Entry retainers start around $1,000 per month with a three-month minimum. Mid-market engagements run $2,500 to $7,500 monthly. Specialist and reputation work starts at $5,000 per project, with typical spends of $7,500 to $25,000. Senior US-based teams bill roughly $100 to $149 per hour.

How Long Does Seo Take To Work In NYC?

Expect early movement on long-tail and neighbourhood terms in three to four months, meaningful lead volume around months six to nine, and competitive head terms at nine to eighteen months. New York timelines run longer than national averages because keyword competition is denser in nearly every vertical.

Is Local Seo Different From Regular Seo In New York?

Yes. Local SEO targets Google Business Profile rankings, map pack placement, and neighbourhood-level queries. Traditional SEO targets organic blue links across broader terms. New York adds a borough layer, so a Brooklyn plumber and a Manhattan plumber compete for entirely different result sets.

Should I Hire A NYC Agency Or One Outside The City?

Location matters less than vertical experience and account seniority. Several strong options serving New York are headquartered in New Jersey, California, or Canada. What matters is whether the team understands your borough-level competition and who specifically works on your account.

What Is GEO And Do I Need It?

GEO stands for generative engine optimisation, structuring content to be cited by ChatGPT, Perplexity, Gemini, and Google AI Overviews. Several New York agencies now offer it as a distinct service. If your buyers research before contacting you, it belongs in scope.

Do Seo Companies In NY Require Long Contracts?

It varies widely. Larger agencies commonly require 12-month commitments, some run six-month minimums, and several Long Island and boutique firms operate month-to-month with no contracts at all. Ask about the term, notice period, and what you retain on exit before signing anything.

Can I Do Seo Myself Instead Of Hiring An Agency?

You can handle Google Business Profile, reviews, and basic on-page work yourself. Technical audits, content strategy at scale, and link acquisition realistically require a team. Most owners lose more in delayed rankings than they save in fees.

How Do I Know If An Seo Company Is Legitimate?

Check for a verifiable physical address, named team members with LinkedIn histories, third-party reviews on Clutch or Google, and published case studies with client names. Ask directly whether work is done in-house or subcontracted, and request access to your own analytics accounts.

What Should Be In An Seo Proposal?

Specific deliverables: number of pages optimised, content pieces per month, technical fixes identified, link targets, and reporting cadence. It should name your account lead, define success metrics tied to leads or revenue, and state contract length and exit terms clearly.

Which New York Industries Are Hardest To Rank For?

Legal, medical, dental, home services, and financial services carry the highest competition and cost per click in the NYC metro. These verticals typically need nine to eighteen months and larger content and link budgets. Niche B2B and specialised professional services move considerably faster.

‍